Wednesday, April 2, 2014

Family and Consumer Sciences Teachers: Is there a shortage of teachers? Or, are programs being shut down due to shortage? Or, is it both?

This past year the Journal of Family and Consumer Sciences put out an article titled, "Family and Consumer Sciences Secondary School Programs:  National Survey Shows Continued Demand for FCS Teachers". 

In this article they state that although student enrollment is down at the high school level the middle school level has maintained its enrollment over the past 10 years. 

There has been somewhat of a national campaign to "Bring Back Home Economics" and although this is vital and prominent in social media it is clear that FCS programs continue to thrive throughout the United States.  Number of students in FCS programs and corresponding teachers are down.  It states that this could be anticipated with continued focus on "core" academic offerings and lack of funding.  And, in some states Career Pathways has left FCS struggle to find its place with the career technical curriculum.  (p44 vol 105, no 4, 2013)

Through out the 80's school budgets were struggling.  Many schools chose to cut electives.  Beside cutting these electives schools were feeling as though courses like "Home Economics" were not vital to education and that children could learn some of the concepts in the Home Economics curriculum at home.  Because of this transition many colleges and universities chose to cut the Home Economics education programs in their schools. 

As the FCS programs leveled off in the 90's many school guidance officials felt that they should not steer children into a career that was facing decline.  Therefore Colleges and Universities that did still have programs were seeing a decline in their FCS enrollment.  In the early 2000 I did a small study in the Minnesota.  During that year the University of Minnesota had 8 graduates in the Masters program and UW Stout had 18  (lower now).  When I graduated from Stout in 1982 there were between 80 and 90 in my graduating class.

Because there were not many jobs available over the late 80's and early 90's very few went into the field.  Now, as we face a time when many of those that started teaching FCS in the late 70's and early 80's face retirement schools are desperate to find replacements for these FCS classes.

Last year Minnesota State University, Mankato, MN received approximately 40 requests for FCS teachers.  They graduated approximately 4 students.  (Note:  The University of Minnesota,  original land grant university, no longer offer a FCS degree)

As we approach the end of the school year we see emails across the Minnesota list serve for open position for the coming school year.  Up until April 1 there have been 6 requests for FCS professionals for the coming school year. 

Schools that struggle with budgets can easily decide to end programs rather than wait until the finale hour to replace retiring FCS professionals.

As a profession, if we do not want to see the field die, several things need to happen to keep it alive.

1.  We must continue to be a positive voice nationally and promote the wonderful work that we do to educate children.

2.  We need to promote our field as a career choice for our FCS students through the courses we teach and extra curricular activities sponsored by FCS.

3.  We need to encourage those that have walked away from the field because jobs were hard to find at one time and "get them back into education". 

4.  Some of us that have left the field might need to go back until replacement can be found.

5. As professionals we need to stay current with trends and teach what is vital to sustain today, rather than what we have always taught. 

Our profession is in a scary state.  Our professional organization is struggling as a whole, our high school and college enrollment is declining and yet we have a shortage of educators to keep the programs that we have alive.

As a group we must be strong, be involved and fight to keep the positive work that we do in the public eye.

With love from your retired FCS teacher, Jane






10 comments:

  1. You are always sharing wonderful insights into our profession; both the joys and struggles we face. Hopefully we will able to maintain this profession as it is one of the very few or the only one that has the capability to provide students with proven skills to succeed in our world today and in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  2. More students need to be encouraged to follow this awesome career path. When schools can't fill positions, the response is often to cut the program. Non-traditional students and teachers from other disciplines should be encouraged to seek FCS certification. They will be glad they did!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Both of the Sue's are spot on.

    ReplyDelete
  4. As a "core" teacher of numerous years, who never took a home ec class in high school (because I was taught by my mother and grandparents how to cook, sew, and budget) I saw the need for the program as I had students that were lacking many basic skills necessary for life (our program was cut when our FACS teacher retired). I went back and got certified to teach FACS, fought with my superintendent over getting me out of the core area (although not completely) by showing him how the "elective" courses could reinforce math, science, history, and English skills including vocabulary and writing. Two years later I have a high demand for my classes, including now needing to add more classes to fill the requests. Parents are excited, superintendent is pleased, and I have several students graduating this year who are looking into going into teaching FACS. I hope we can see a comeback of a very necessary program. As I told my superintendent, "We have spent years preparing students for college and for careers, but we have failed to prepare them for life".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wonderful news! Thank you for being a FACS cheerleader and entering the field. This is a great story and inspiration!

      Delete
  5. I was one of those awesome graduates from MSU, Mankato (Spring of 2013)! It hasn't been quite a year since graduation, and I can't help but to LOVE where my education has taken me! I am so fortunate to be a first year teacher in such an awesome area, in which I am one of two new hires in the FCS department in the high school. We are slowly revamping the FCS department by integrating technology in a thought to be not so tech-savy area! My partner in crime (other department teacher) put a spin and updated sense within our classes, and only see our class numbers dramatically increasing! Our school also supports our department by requiring our Parenting class for graduation! I believe it is important to help remind students that being a FCS teacher is "real job"- often times my students forget that I am a real teacher, because I am so passionate about the subject areas in which we teach! FCS rocks! :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love your enthusiasm Katie! Keep up the good work and continue to support Family and Consumer Sciences!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Very interesting article! I always enjoy your website. I wonder, due to the shortage of FACS teachers in some states, would some school districts employ Foreign teachers like me who is currently studying a Bachelor of Education in Home Economics and Economics in Ireland. I would love to seek employment in the USA in 2016 when I graduate.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Very interesting article! I always enjoy your website. I wonder, due to the shortage of FACS teachers in some states, would some school districts employ Foreign teachers like me who is currently studying a Bachelor of Education in Home Economics and Economics in Ireland. I would love to seek employment in the USA in 2016 when I graduate.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Elaine, I look at you post all of the time and never know what to say. I hope that you have found you FACS position. I would say that you may have to take a test or two to get you license but please do inquire. Still a shortage. Jane

    ReplyDelete